Here are a few polished, natural-sounding ways to complete your caption, depending on the tone you want:
đź’› Warm & simple
“My mom used to make this and it was delicious! So grateful to have found it again. I made it last night and it was just as amazing as I remembered.”
🍞 Slightly viral / engaging
“My mom used to make this and it was so good! I finally found the recipe and tried it last night… and wow, it really lives up to its name!”
🏡 Nostalgic tone
“This was something my mom used to make when I was younger—so delicious and comforting. I’m so thankful I found the recipe. I made it last night and it brought back so many memories.”
✨ Short version
“My mom used to make this—so glad I found the recipe again. I made it last night and it was absolutely delicious!”
If you want, I can also turn it into a full viral post with hashtags and a hook line.